What are Vladimir Putin’s choices after Russian navy setback in Ukraine? By Reuters

By Andrew Osborn

LONDON (Reuters) – Russian President Vladimir Putin has but to publicly touch upon a lightning rout of his forces in north-eastern Ukraine, however is underneath strain from nationalists at house to regain the initiative.

He has few fast repair choices, if Western intelligence and open supply evaluation is correct, and many of the potential steps he may take include home and geopolitical dangers.

Since coming to energy in 1999, Islamist militants in Chechnya and the broader North Caucasus area are among the many hardest armed foes Putin has confronted. In that occasion, he selected to escalate with extra pressure.

These are a few of his foremost choices in Ukraine:

STABILISE, REGROUP, ATTACK

Russian and Western navy analysts agree that — from Moscow’s perspective — Russian forces must urgently stabilise the frontline, halt Ukraine’s advance, regroup and, if they’ll, launch their very own counter offensive. There are nevertheless doubts within the West about whether or not Russia has the bottom forces or ample tools, given what number of casualties it has taken and the way a lot {hardware} has been deserted or destroyed throughout what Russia calls its “particular navy operation” to destroy the Ukrainian military.

“There isn’t any manpower,” Konrad Muzyka, director of Poland’s Rochan Consulting, mentioned after Russia’s setback within the north-east.

“Volunteer battalions are underneath power, and the recruitment marketing campaign is just not delivering what was anticipated. And I feel it’ll solely worsen as fewer males will now wish to be a part of. If Moscow needs so as to add males, it must conduct a mobilisation.”

Russian efforts to extend the variety of troops it could deploy embody the formation of a brand new third Military Corps, Chechen chief Ramzan Kadyrov marshalling new forces, and Putin final month signing a decree to extend the scale of Russia’s armed forces.

Putin might want to determine whether or not to conform to calls for from nationalist critics that he sack or reshuffle the navy’s prime brass, together with Defence Minister Sergei Shoigu, an in depth ally. Putin has historically not given in to speedy strain to fireplace subordinates, however has typically parted firm with them at a later date.

MOBILISATION

Mobilising Russia’s reserves, who quantity round 2 million males with navy service inside the previous 5 years, is doable but it surely takes occasions to coach and deploy folks.

The Kremlin mentioned on Tuesday there was no dialogue of a nationwide mobilisation “in the intervening time.”

Such a transfer can be standard with nationalists, however much less so with some Russian males in city centres who, anecdotal proof suggests, are much less eager on becoming a member of the battle.

It could imply recalibrating official messaging on Ukraine and shifting away from describing it as “a particular navy operation” with restricted targets to an open-ended warfare.

That in flip would pressure the authorities to desert their coverage of attempting to make sure that the lives of most Russians go on as they did earlier than Feb. 24 when Putin invaded Ukraine.

Placing Russia on a full wartime footing would include home political dangers too, notably the chance of a public backlash in opposition to a pressured draft.

It could additionally represent an admission that Russia is engaged in a full-scale warfare in opposition to a fellow Slav nation – and that the warfare goes badly for Moscow.

Andrey Kortunov, head of RIAC, a assume tank near the Russian international ministry, has mentioned he believes the authorities are reluctant on mobilisation.

“In massive cities many individuals don’t wish to go and battle and mobilisation is just not prone to be standard,” mentioned Kortunov.

“Secondly I feel it’s arguably in Putin’s pursuits to current the entire thing as a restricted operation. The state want to protect as a lot as attainable because it was earlier than with out making any radical adjustments.”

Tony Brenton, a former British ambassador to Russia, has mentioned it will take months earlier than a mobilisation would have any impact on Russia’s combating power in any case.

BET ON ‘GENERAL WINTER’

Two Russian sources accustomed to Kremlin pondering informed Reuters final month that Putin is hoping that sky-rocketing vitality costs and attainable shortages this winter will persuade Europe to robust arm Ukraine right into a truce — on Russia’s phrases.

Some European diplomats imagine that Ukraine’s latest battlefield success has undermined the urge of some Europeans to push Kyiv to make concessions nevertheless, whereas international locations like Germany seem to have grown more durable on Moscow in latest weeks and extra decided to experience out winter vitality issues.

The European Union has banned Russian coal and authorized a partial ban on Russian imports. Russia in flip has sharply minimize gasoline exports to Europe and made clear it may ban all vitality exports, a lever Putin has but to drag.

EXPAND MISSILE TARGETING

After its setback in north-east Ukraine, Russia struck Ukrainian energy infrastructure with missiles. That brought about short-term blackouts within the Kharkiv and adjoining Poltava and Sumy areas. Water provides and cell networks had been additionally affected.

The transfer was cheered by some Russian nationalists who want to see Moscow use cruise missiles to cripple Ukrainian infrastructure on a extra everlasting foundation, a transfer sure to draw worldwide condemnation.

The identical nationalists have additionally lengthy referred to as for Moscow to strike what they name “decision-making” centres in Kyiv and elsewhere, one thing that it’s unlikely may very well be achieved with out vital collateral injury.

END OR DOWNGRADE GRAIN DEAL

Putin has complained {that a} U.N. and Turkey-brokered deal that permits Ukraine to export grain and different foodstuffs through the Black Sea is unfair to poorer international locations and Russia.

Putin is because of holds talks this week with Turkish chief Tayyip Erdogan to debate revising the deal, which gives Ukraine with a lot wanted funds revenues. If Putin needs to right away harm Ukraine he may droop or cancel the pact or refuse to resume it when it expires in November. The West and poorer international locations in Africa and the Center East would accuse him of worsening world meals shortages; he would blame Ukraine.

PEACE DEAL

The Kremlin says it’ll dictate to Kyiv the phrases of any peace deal when the time comes, whereas Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy has mentioned he’ll use pressure to liberate his nation.

Zelenskiy has mentioned that features Crimea, which Russia annexed in 2014. Moscow has repeatedly mentioned that Crimea’s standing is settled eternally.

Conceding captured territory in japanese Ukraine within the Russian-backed self-proclaimed Donetsk Folks’s Republic or Luhansk Folks’s Republic additionally seems politically unattainable for Moscow because it has formally recognised them.

Totally “liberating” the 2 self-proclaimed statelets from Ukrainian forces was one of many foremost causes given for the “particular navy operation” within the first place.

Handing again captured territory in southern Ukraine the place Russia partially controls three areas seems like a tough home promote too.

The southern Kherson area is straight north of annexed Crimea and the placement of a canal which provides the Black Sea peninsula with most of its water.

Together with the neighbouring Zaporizhzhia area, Kherson additionally offers Russia a land hall by way of which it could provide Crimea, one thing Moscow has touted as a significant prize.

GO NUCLEAR

Russian authorities officers have dismissed Western recommendations that Moscow would use tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine, but it surely stays a fear for some within the West.

Other than inflicting mass casualties, such a transfer may begin a harmful escalatory spiral and formally draw Western international locations right into a direct warfare with Russia.

Russia’s nuclear doctrine permits for the usage of nuclear weapons in the event that they – or different sorts of weapons of mass destruction – are used in opposition to it, or if the Russian state faces an existential menace from standard weapons.

Putin, in a quasi-autobiography in 2000, recalled cornering a rat in a nook with a stick when rising up in a dilapidated condominium constructing in then Leningrad and being stunned when the cornered animal threw itself at him and turned the tables.

Brenton, the previous British ambassador to Russia, has warned {that a} cornered Putin may go nuclear if he confronted a humiliating defeat with no face-saving off-ramp.

“If the selection for Russia is combating a shedding warfare, and shedding badly and Putin falling, or some form of nuclear demonstration, I would not wager that they would not go for the nuclear demonstration,” mentioned Brenton.

Retired U.S. normal Ben Hodges, former commander of U.S. Military forces in Europe, agrees it is a danger however has mentioned he thinks it unlikely.

“There isn’t any actual battlefield benefit to be gained, it will be unattainable for (the) U.S. to remain out/not reply, and I do not assume Putin or his closest advisers are suicidal,” mentioned Hodges.